I found an interesting article over on the Anchoress' blog. It's a piece from 1941 about the character of different types of Americans and whether or not they'd join the Nazis. It's definitely worth the read. But you can apply the same principle today. But instead of asking whether a person is a Nazi, ask whether a person is a statist. Play a game the next time you're in a group and see if you can determine who believes the State should tell them what to do, who would join the State just because it's the most powerful, who would oppose the State; ask how people would react to the State controlling everything. And more importantly, ask why. What is it about the person, his character, that would make him act the way he does?
The road to freedom and the restoration of the republic has more to do with the Founders' "Public Virtue" than almost anything else. Time will prove me right, but the longer you let this go, the more painful The Reckoning.
I have faith and stubbornness. Put them together and you have a dynamic duo. When I come to a brick wall, I can go over it, I can go under it, I can go around it, I can just go through it. I don't know what I'm going to do, but I'm getting to the other side.
And David Ring's ultimate challenge to people who think something can't be done: "I have cerebral palsy. What's your problem?"
Some of us are willing to tolerate any sort of personal ridicule in order to avoid supporting the wrong decisions;
The rest of us are willing to support all kinds of wrong decisions, in order to escape any sort of ridicule.
An insightful comment on the difference between liberals and not-liberals. Freeberg calls it Yin and Yang, where Yin are the people who go out and build things, and Yang are the people who socialize and network.
The Yin theory is actually a very accurate description of my life. I'm a builder by nature; I spent my entire childhood playing with LEGOs or K'Nex. Yes, there was running around outside with the standard compliment of boy's toys (GI Joes, Nerf guns, bat and ball), but I spent an equal amount of time making things. I didn't bother developing social skills until I got to high school, and was well in to college before they were sufficiently advanced that I could deal with people normally.
What is critical to Freeberg's theory is that for a Yin to make something, he has to understand how things actually work. If his knowledge of reality is wrong, what he makes won't work. And he is forced by his experiences to modify his knowledge of reality. See engineers for further details.
The Yang, however, want to show that they have the right social connections. They have to show they are connected to the right people, and distinguish themselves from those who are not. But fashion and popularity aren't really constrained by physics, so they can go in any bizarre direction.
Which brings us back to the quote at the top. Some people want the right answer, and some people want to belong. Very often we have to pick one or the other.
I'd rather be right than popular.
Update: Welcome House of Eratosthenes readers!
I have returned from the Great Debate and I am rather disappointed in both sides. The first part of the debate mostly consisted of D'Souza and Hitchens making assertions. They rarely addressed anything brought up by their opponent, and provided little, if any, reasoning or evidence for their beliefs. In this regard, I think D'Souza did slightly better than Hitchens, but I could only understand his arguments because I had read his book What's So Great About Christianity. I can only guess at Hitchens line of reason, because it was never stated.
Which puts my predictions for the debate way off. Hitchens made no personal attacks, and only a few sarcastic remarks, some of them directed at the moderator. Hitchens was definitely the more entertaining of the debaters. I do, however, give the money quote of the debate to D'Souza. Towards the end of the debate, each person was allowed to ask their opponent one question. Hitchens asked if D'Souza would rather Hitchens stay an atheist, or convert to some non-Christian religion, like Islam. S'Souza's reply: "It's much safer to debate you as an atheist than a Muslim."
I thought there were a number of fallacies and historical in Hitchens assertions, but D'Souza never dug into them. And D'Souza's arguments were not as strong as they could have been. He could have used some additional evidence and reasoning.
The last part of the debate was a little more lively. The moderator took a few questions from the audience, and Hitchens or D'Souza gave a short answer, and then the other gave a short rebuttal, and they did a bit of back and forth until the moderator cut them off. This is where Hitchens made some of his more egregious claims (the Nazis were a Christian group, the Communist founded a state church based off Eastern Orthodoxy to worship Stalin) that just don't stand up to the historical test. I'm not going to analyze or refute Hitchens' arguments until I've had a chance to read God is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, since I really don't know more about Hitchens' position except that he believes every evil in the world is caused by religion and he thinks that religion is immoral because of it. So I want to get his take on that where he has a chance to explain in detail his beliefs.
It was an interesting debate, but I didn't really learn anything from it. I'd heard most of the arguments from both sides before, and without much explanation for their assertions, the ones that were new didn't mean much to me. It was more to see how the two men debated than to really learn anything. It looks like formal debates are terrible forums for either informing or persuading.
The topic we were discussing in men's Bible study the other day was moral law. One of the sticking points was whether moral law comes from an outside source, or whether it is made up by society. Obviously, Christians believe that moral law comes from an outside source; God. Whereas evolutionists and many other scholars believe that moral law is made up by society.
Where Calvinball comes in is with an analogy that was used to describe moral law. In almost all games, the rules are made up by an outside source. The players don't make up the rules as they go. Nor do they even agree on the rules before the game starts. The rules exist from beforehand, whether in basketball or Monopoly, and the players are expected to follow them. This is our outside source. The rules of play are created by some external entity and anyone who wants to play the game follows those rules.
In Calvinball, however, the players make up rules as they go. Rules are invented and disbanded at whim. This is the evolutionary theory, where people make up rules to progress themselves, and eventually eliminate them when they are no longer useful.
Both approaches to games are possible. You and your buddies can make up your own rules and have a great time. Or you can play an existing game and have a great time. But in real life, the question is whether moral law is absolute or relative. For it to be absolute, it must come from an outside source. And by outside, I mean outside of humanity. Any objective standard is external to the thing being measured.
With relative moral law, we can invent and modify right and wrong however it suits us. But in a dispute, whose right and wrong do we use? Whoever has the bigger stick. If right and wrong are social constructs, then whoever has the power to enforce the standard gets to set the standard. But if the standard changes, it's not really standard.
Which is shiny and all, but it doesn't really tell us which of these theories is correct. Either we're all playing basketball, even if we don't know the rules and are inclined to cheat, or we are playing Calvinball, and only use rules we like.
Maybe I should go read some more Calvin & Hobbes and see what other theology I can discover.
But I'm not the only one saying it.
This speech was given by Evan Sayet to the Heritage Foundation two years ago. He gave a followup speech this week.
My favorite line was this one:
Stupidity is a luxury and you will find time and time and time again that those who are overwhelmingly on the left are those who can afford to be. Those who do not suffer the consequences of their stupidity...
Hat Tip: Big Hollywood and Right Wing News
So Gtmunch just sent me a link about an Orlando Tea Party this weekend. I think it will be an interesting adventure. This will be my first foray into political activism. I wanted to write down a few thoughts before casting my lot.
Of great concern to me is the vast difference between my view of the world, and that of the liberals. It is only in the last two years that I have begun to discover the various, fundamental beliefs that make up a person's philosophy on life, the universe, and everything. I started this blog in part to write down what my beliefs are, how they compare to other philosophies, and how they all play out in the world.
And what I have found in my learning is that these different worldviews are not compatible. They contradict. Which means at least one of them has to be wrong. It's simple logic; the law of non-contradiction.
But it is more than just right and wrong. For I do not believe that liberal philosophy merely wrong, I believe that liberal philosophy is the most destructive force in society today. It's not something over which I can compromise. But this puts me in a very awkward position. My beliefs place me in direct opposition to my government. I consider what the Democrats are doing in Washington to be evil. They are systematically destroying American civilization.
That's one hell of a statement. But I can't come to any other conclusion. I believe that the best society is that which is built upon Biblical teachings. The humanist and naturalist philosophies that underpin liberalism are in direct opposition to Christianity. And they know it. That is why Christianity has been ever more marginalized for the last century by progressive policy makers.
The government wishes to mandate how we should live our lives; tell us what proper behavior is, and beliefs are taboo. Which is also what Christianity does (and Islam, and Judaism, and Buddhism, and so on).
So I think the best I can do is live my life according to the teachings of Christ to the best of my ability.
Which brings us back to the Tea Party protests. I really can't tell how much affect they are having. I don't think the powers that be in Washington care at all. So as far as policy goes, I think it's a complete wash. However, it does let people know that they are not alone in disagreeing with their government. But I really don't expect it to go as far as the original Boston Tea Party. Even though we are far more aggrieved than the Colonists. Nobody really wants an armed insurrection against the most powerful nation in the world. It might have worked 233 years ago, but the deck is considerably more stacked in government's favor today, and few people are willing to give up their lives, fortunes, and sacred honor, since life is still pretty damned good for most of us.
The cumulative number of women who have posed topless on the internet doubles every eighteen months.I was doing chores this evening, and my mind started having strange philosophical discussions with itself. I mean, what else is it supposed to do while I vacuum and mop? At any rate, I got onto the topic of pornography. It is a continual problem for every man, and definitely one I struggle with (on the occasion that I actually struggle, instead of giving right it).Unknown
But what caught my mind's eye was the conventional Christian wisdom on pornography. Namely, that it desensitizes men to sex and sexual acts, causes men to disrespect women , and treat them as nothing more than sex objects.
The problem is that that narrative doesn't really match up with my experiences. I do not feel that I treat women with disrespect, or only think about having sex. Nor do I feel more inclined to behave that way after viewing porn. And of the men I know who have viewed porn (or still do), all of them are well behaved towards women. So either I've only met the outliers, or the conventional wisdom is lacking.
It seems to me that pornography is more of a symptom of society's problems with the relationship between men and women, rather than a cause. That disrespect and sexual objectification are more prevalent is obvious (hello rap culture), but I think that has more to do with America's growing self-centeredness. The it's-all-about-me-I-don't-care-about-anyone-else attitude and the loosening and often outright abandonment of moral restrictions leads to disrespectful, degrading behavior, since one is concerned with one's own pleasures, and not whether that hurts someone else.
And that seems to me where porn lies. It is selfish. It is sexual gratification without the hassle of getting a woman's permission first. Actually, right there I can see how pornography can contribute to this problem. Like any other form of selfishness, when you become used to indulging in your pleasures at your whim, suddenly finding yourself restricted in a similar area (say your girlfriend isn't in the mood) will make you resentful.
But this does put the root cause on our own selfishness, and our growing inability to deal with it when we don't get what we want when we want it. So it looks like the Church does have a point and pornography does feed the problem. But what the Church misses (or I have missed) is that the problem is the continual selfish indulgence in every sin to the point we get angry when we can't indulge for some reason. Pornography and sexual degradation are the problems associated with lust. I bet it would be easy to find obvious examples of the other deadly sins.
And this also explains why my own experiences did not match the conventional wisdom. We (my Christian friends and I) understand and accept that we can't always get our way, and that selfishness is wrong, so we don't flip out when the universe doesn't cater to our whims. So while we unfortunately still indulge in our own favorite sins, the Holy Spirit keeps it from dominating our lives.
It's time for another long article on worldviews and philosophies and how they form the foundation of our actions. Our underlying premise here is that your beliefs, your view of how the world works, whether you know those beliefs or not, determines how you act in the world. As opposed to your actions being simply random. There is a method to the madness. The reason I want to know how and why the world works, why I want a coherent and comprehensive worldview, is that I want to make informed decisions. The reason I want to know other people's philosophies is so that I can take their probable actions into account.
And here I must make an important distinction. A worldview does not necessarily conform to reality. That is, some people accept as fundamental truths things that are not true. But their actions may be reasonable based on that belief. The question is, what are those fundamental beliefs, both the ones that are true and the ones that people only think are true? What do people really believe? And is it really real?
Differences in what people accept as truth cause most of the partisanship in America today. The biggest point of contention is what to do about this economic crisis. On the right side, we have people saying that government regulation created a bubble that has now popped, and to fix it, the government needs to leave things alone and let the free market sort things out. On the left, people are saying that immoral capitalists created a bubble at the expense of everyone else, and to fix it, the government needs to take over everything to prevent any kind of unfairness. Both sides are claiming the other side's solution was the root problem.
Or at least that's what the people in general appear to believe. The Democrats in power seem to be playing by Saul Alinsky's rules, and while that says a lot about their beliefs, it doesn't say much about their beliefs about the economy. So what are people's beliefs about the economy? The ones they base their actions on, not the ones they just say they have.
We're going to approach this problem rather obliquely. And we'll start with a simple question: what is wealth? Wealth is stuff. It is the food you eat, the clothes you wear, the house you live in, your shiny baubles, electronic gadgets, tools, art, toys. Wealth is the physical things you consume or collect because you value you them for some reason or another.
I like this definition because it is both absolute and easily quantifiable. Absolute in that you either have a thing or you don't. You either have a big screen TV or you don't. Quantifiable because you can determine who has a thing and how good a thing is. Who has a TV and how big is it. I think most people accept this definition of wealth.
If that is wealth, then it follows that wealth is created when people make stuff. At the very front end, wealth is made from the raw materials found in nature, whether food from a fertile field, wood from a stand of trees, or metal from mined ore. The this raw wealth is combined and modified ad infinitum until stuff people want is produced. An iPod is a long way from the raw ore and oil that went in to its component parts, but that's what it was when it was dug out of the ground. Again, I think most people accept that for stuff to exist, someone has to make it.
But who gets the stuff? Do you get to keep what you make? Or do you put whatever you make in the global commons for whoever needs or wants it? Most people believe that the things you make are yours. If you make a bookshelf, it's your bookshelf. You may keep it or give it away or trade it as you choose. When you are talking physical things that an individual has made, people expect to keep and do what they want with what they have made. See this incident reported by House of Eratosthenes. And yet the idea that the things a person has made should be taken by the government and given to someone else persists.
Let's revisit our definition of wealth. Notice what this definition excludes. Money. Money is not stuff. It is a medium of exchange, a measure of the relative worth of the actual stuff. How many purses to the giant TV? A currency allows everything that people make to be ranked on a common scale. A person makes X number of purses and sells them for Y amount of the currency. That person then goes to someone who has a TV and buys it. He has effectively traded his purses for a TV. But the wealth is the purses and the TV, not the money used to make the trade.
But that means that borrowing more money or printing more currency doesn't affect the amount of stuff. Or even the relative worth of stuff. It just changes the absolute number at which the stuff is valued. You can only trade what you really have. If you have two purses, you cannot trade away three of them. When you trade for a TV, you want the TV now, not six months down the road.
This is our first disconnect. Some people see that money buys stuff, and the more money, the more stuff. If you stop there, then acquiring money to buy stuff is reasonable. It doesn't really matter where the money comes from, so long as your relative amount of it goes up. Take it from someone else, print more of it, borrow indefinitely, with more money you can buy more stuff. And with more stuff, your relative wealth goes up.
But in none of those do you actually produce any wealth. You merely consume. Conservatives believe that stuff is wealth. Therefore, to get stuff, you must make stuff which is yours, and then trade it around for other stuff that you want or need. Liberals believe that money is wealth. Therefore, to get money, you can print, borrow, sell, or steal, and then exchange it for stuff that you want or need.
This is why I have not been overly bothered by the current recession. I make stuff (software) that people want. I sell it to them (or strictly speaking I sell it to the company I work for, who the sells it to other people). I go buy things I want that other people have made. Nice, neat, and simple. And as long as I make stuff people want, I can get wealth.
But notice something else. Because I see wealth as stuff, borrowing means I take stuff from someone now and promise to make them stuff at some point in the future. Well, at that some point, that someone will want the stuff I promised them. If I can deliver, great. If I cannot, I am in trouble, because now I have stolen their stuff. So I try to borrow as little as possible. But if money is wealth, then you are not delivering stuff in the future, so you don't have to worry about making any. You can just give them money you got from somewhere.
But the problem is that people insist on having stuff instead of just a bank account. So everyone who borrowed money to acquire stuff is being asked to produce some stuff so that the lenders can acquire stuff. That stuff has failed to materialize, so people are trading stuff for stuff, instead of stuff for future stuff, and we've ended up with a huge market correction. And this problem will continue so long as people continue to confuse currency with actual, physical stuff.
An extensive survey by the Pew Research Center found that three out of four Republicans believe that people can get ahead by working hard. Four out of five believe that everyone has the power to succeed. But Democrats have much less faith in the value of hard work. Only 14 percent believe that people can get ahead by working hard, according to the survey. And only 44 percent believe that everyone has the power to succeed. This is not a case of 'rich' Republicans believing one thing and 'poor' Democrats another. Even when you compare Republicans and Democrats of the same income, the gap still exists.
John Eberhard
This isn't really surprising news. Based on behavior, liberals want to redistribute success, and conservatives want to earn it for themselves. (Quick question: would the discrepancy be more pronounced if respondents to the survey had identified as liberal or conservative instead of Democrat or Republican?) The real question we need to ask ourselves is why.
My father has had to work with Muslims on business. One of the things he told me is that Muslims don't believe in planning ahead or working hard or otherwise doing things of their own initiative. They wait on Allah's will to give them success. They believe that what will happen will happened, regardless of what they do. They don't believe in cause and effect.
Liberals seem very much in the same mindset. They have replaced Allah with random chance, but they still deny that their actions have a relation to their circumstances, success or failure. This is a very irrational position, as it accepts that other people can affect your circumstances, but you have no affect on your circumstances. I really don't understand why someone would want to place himself in a position of helplessness.
But I do know why I work hard. One, I work hard because God has made me a steward of His creation. I am responsible for my little bit of it and want to do well by it in God's eyes. This is called the Protestant work ethic. The second reason I work hard is so that I can gain the various luxuries that make life more enjoyable, from my own home, an over sized TV, or the ability to travel to far off locales. This is called the American Dream.
Hat Tip: Conservative Grapevine
I am reading through Dinesh D'Souza's book What's so Great About Christianity. In part 5 of his book, he talks about the limits of reason and senses and empirical evidence, and Pascal's Wager. I want to go a little deeper into Pascal's Wager.
Pascal's Wager begins as follows: either God exists, or God does not exist. These are the only two logical possibilities. Likewise, we as humans can only make two choices, to believe God exists, or to believe God does not exist. Since it is impossible to know with absolute certainty whether or not God exists, Pascal analyzes the risks and rewards associated with each choice in light of each possible truth, and comes to the conclusion that it is reasonable to believe in God.
Here's how it goes. If God does not exist, and choose not to believe in God, then I can do whatever I want on this earth, and the afterlife does not matter, because there is no afterlife. There are no eternal consequences to our actions or beliefs. Therefore, I can do whatever I want on this earth that pleases me. But if God does not exist and I choose to believe in God, then I make sacrifices to live a good life, but I get no eternal rewards. Therefore I have not done whatever pleases me, and all for nothing. Though it should be noted that many people are still satisfied with this life.
If God exists, and I choose to believe in God, then I make sacrifices to live a good life, and in return I go to heaven in the afterlife where I receive rewards from God for all eternity. But if God exists and I choose to not believe in God, then I do whatever I want on this earth that pleases me, and in return, God sends me to hell for eternal punishment.
This being the case, Pascal states that it is better to believe in God, because if you are wrong, you have not done everything you wanted, but probably still lived a satisfying life, but if you are right, you are given eternal rewards. The rewards are great and the risk is low. Contrast that to not believing in God, where if you may do as you please, but if you are wrong, you are eternally punished. The reward is low and the risk is high. Therefore a reasonable person should choose to believe in God.
But now I want to look at whether the wager is even valid or not. For the wager to be valid, two conditions must be met:
- First, we must not be able to know whether or not God exists. For if we know which is true, then there is no need to make the wager in the first place. We simply choose to believe the truth.
- Second, we have to have made an accurate assessment of the risks and rewards. If believing in God leads to atrocities, then the risk of believing in God and being wrong is much higher than if believing in God leads to good behavior. Similarly, if not believing in God leads to atrocities, then the rewards of being right are not as great as we would assume.
So can we know, with absolute certainty, whether God exists or not? According to Kant and Hume, the answer is no, since we cannot know anything with absolute certainty.
Kant's position was that since we can only perceive the world through our human senses, we cannot know everything there is to know. What we can see, hear, touch, taste, and smell is only a portion of the universe. There are things beyond our senses. And even the devices we build to see beyond our senses merely translates something into something else we can perceive. Because of this limitation, there is no way to verify if what we perceive is true. We have only our senses, and to use the senses to prove the senses is circular. Therefore, everything we know about the world is based on the unproven assumption that our senses are accurate.
Hume had a different take. Hume stated that all our scientific knowledge is based on empirical observation. That is, we repeat something many times and measure how it behaves. The problem with empiricism is that it is not proof. It is evidence, yes, but for it to be proof, you have to observe every single instance of the cause and see the same effect. So while we may be confident that X causes Y, observing X then Y many times with a very high correlation does not mean that there are not cases where X happens and then Y doesn't happen.
So while we may be very confident of God's existence or not, we cannot know with certainty. So the first premise of Pascal's Wager is satisfied.
So now let us look at the risks and rewards. We shall start with the eternal risks and rewards first. If God does not exist, then there are no eternal rewards. Nor are there eternal risks. There is no box on the other side of life we have to fill in in order to make our assessment. There are no positives or negatives. But if God does exist, then the reward is eternity with Him in His heaven. Whether you call it heaven or paradise, you receive what makes you happy and satisfied for all time. (Whether what you receive is what you think makes you happy is another discussion). But the risk is the opposite. Eternal suffering. For some it is living in a pit of flame and despair forever. For others, it is returning to live again on the earth. (This last had more impact before the Europeans created ubiquitous luxuries and living was actually hard). So if God exists, it's eternal bliss or eternal suffering.
But what about the temporal risks and rewards, those that affect us in this life? If God does not exist, then there is no moral truth, no right and wrong. There is no transcendent meaning to our lives. The universe just is, for no particular reason, and we just are, for no other reason than because the universe just is. And that's all we've got and we can do with it as we will.
For those who accept this as truth, they are free of all moral obligations, and can do anything their heart desires. And the only limit on this is what others (such as society) allow them to do. Might makes right, for their are no other external limits on behavior. So the reward is to do whatever you can get away with. But the risk is that someone could come and do whatever to you.
For those who believe that God exists when he does not, they are deluding themselves. They may be content in this life, believing that ultimately everyone will get their just rewards, but won't ever find out that they are wrong, since they just cease to exist upon death. In the meantime, they place limits on their behavior. They do not do everything they want, because sometimes God says it's actually bad for you, and sometimes what they want hurts others, and God doesn't want them to hurt others. This prevents anarchy and armed conflict and generally allows people to get along, so most people, even those who don't believe in God, consider it a good thing. However, in their zealousness, the believer often imposes these limits on the non-believers. The non-believers do not like this, especially in cases where the harm of the behavior is not obvious. This can cause conflict, and would be the downside of believing in a God who does not exist.
Interestingly, the temporal risks and rewards are very similar if God does exist. For those who do not believe in God, they still have no moral limits or meaning to their lives. And they are still in conflict with those who do accept the morality of God and the meaning He gives to life. What changes is that if God exists, He can step in and give blessings to those believe in Him, and withhold them, or even punish, those who do not.
So for assessing risks and rewards of God's existence, they are mostly tied to eternity after death, with the temporal rewards being driven largely by our own choice. So it is still reasonable to believe in God even if we aren't sure, because the rewards in the here and hereafter are greater, while the risks of not believing are higher, both in the here and now and in eternity. So the second premise is satisfied.
I have, over the past year, begun developing a philosophy to life. A worldview, if you will, that gives a foundation for knowing how things work and how best to deal with life. I first started thinking about my understanding of the world when my bible study did a series called the Truth Project. Its goal was to explain the Christian philosophy.
What makes this remarkable was that this was the first time I had ever heard of philosophy explained as a holistic foundation from which to approach life. I had gotten the impression in school that philosophy was a pointless exercise in debating and explaining things that nobody in the real world thinks about and has no bearing on one's decisions. The Truth Project showed me what the point of a philosophy is, and why it's worth thinking about.
Namely, that everyone has a philosophy. That is, the set of foundational beliefs that drives a person's decisions. You may not know what those beliefs are, and they may not have an 'ism' attached to them, but somewhere, there is something that makes you choose option A over option B. This is what drives people. It explains why people do the things they do. Something which often takes some serious explaining.
With my philosophical foundation being Christianity, I start off with an assertion that directly contradicts society: people are basically evil. People put themselves first, seeking after their own desires and pleasures, and only secondly, if at all, think of others. However, most Westerners seldom think of fulfilling your desires and pleasures as evil. Didn't Maslow say that self-actualization was the highest form of being? But they never seem to think that most people self-actualize at the expense of others. If your goal is yourself, then what do you care if you have to rape to get sex, or steal to get money?
But of course, those are the exceptions, not the rule, right? If people are really evil, why do we have the idea of progressivism, the idea that people are good and working to make things better? Perhaps somebody should tell Darfur that they are basically good people. But here in America's favorite baseline for everyone in the world, we are raised with Christian morals and values. Which seek to curtail our evil desires. Morals which most people don't have. Americans simply don't think of murder as a form of advancement.
So I behave according to the idea that people are evil and only moral teachings (Christianity does not have a monopoly on these) keep people from being totally depraved. This means I should expect, as moral teachings are more and more removed from society, that Americans will become more selfish and more likely to harm others in seeking their desires, with the level of harm increasing. Which, anecdotally, seems to be the case.
Believing people to be selfish rather than altruistic gives rise to a number of interesting realizations. First, you can't really trust people. Or perhaps I should say you trust people to work in their interest and not yours. So if you want something from someone, be it honesty, goods, or help, you have to make it in their interest to give it to you. Else why should they bother? There are any number of ways to make someone help you, but payment and force seem to be the most popular. So I can take what I want by force, or simply buy it from you.
Force is easy to understand. I get what I want and you get to live. Or you're strong enough yourself to keep me from bothering you. Of course, I could get some buddies to tip things in my favor, splitting the loot, but then, so could you. This ends when one side wipes out the other, or 'buddies' grows into nations and everybody goes bankrupt with a military industrial complex.
Or we can come up with some other method of getting your cooperation, one that doesn't involve wasting time or resources trying to take...your time and resources. Such as payment. I convince you that it is more profitable to give me some of your stuff in exchange for some of my stuff, rather simply taking all your stuff outright. Perhaps at the end of the day, we are both better off with the trade than if we'd devoted time and resources to fighting and taking whatever is left.
But we still have to keep each other honest in our dealings (or at least honest enough). If you have overwhelming force, it's easy to keep me in line, but the idea was to not spend everything on fighting (so you can spend it on yourself, remember). You could stop trading with me and tell other traders I'm too dishonest to trade with. Or you could start trading dishonestly yourself. Of course, I could force you to trade with me, but now we're right back at using force to coerce good behavior. But we have changed the dynamic somewhat. You want to trade, because you know is often times more profitable than conquest. So you need strength of arms to prevent me from taking from you. But you only need enough strength to make it too expensive to be worth invading. As more people figure this out, those who trade will become richer, and stronger, than those who simply fight.
So from the biblical premise that all men are evil, selfish beings, we arrive at not only the foundational logic for capitalism, but also with maintaining a relatively strong fighting force to keep people from taking advantage of each other. This also reveals the fatal flaw of capitalism, that what's good for me is not necessarily good for you, and a strong arbiter is needed to prevent me from forcing deals that only go my way. The use of force, either to coerce good behavior, or for theft and conquest, is a natural outworking of men being evil, and capitalism cannot escape it.
But what of capitalism's big rival, socialism (called welfare in America)? The idea behind socialism is that each person contributes what they can, and each person takes what they need, regardless of how much they put in or how much they need. What you put in the pot is unrelated to what you take out. If people are good, with a natural inclination to share, this would actually work. But if people are evil, they will quickly realize they can simply not produce anything, but still take what they want. This will lead to poverty as production approaches zero, or someone will come in with a big stick and force people to produce. The historical examples of each should be obvious.
I will end with a prediction, since the point of a philosophy is to understand the world enough to make informed decisions. And while it might be many years, perhaps decades, before I'm proven right or wrong, it is worth writing down so that I and others can look back and take note.
As America implements more and more socialist policies, and by this I mean wealth redistribution by which the wealth of those who produce is given to those who do not, the per capita income will go down, and the GDP of America will shrink. Left unchecked, America will come to resemble a third world country, eventually unable to provide even for the basic needs of its people. This will happen quickly enough that people will remember living in the land of prosperity.
This will be stopped in one of two ways; either people realize socialism doesn't work and they go back to capitalism, at which point wealth flows back through America, or America becomes so poor that it can no longer force socialism, and America splits in rebellion and civil war, as each person or group tries to find wealth outside of socialism.
All this, just from believing people are evil.
For as long as I can remember, I have been an individualist. I've never gone along with the group for the sake of going along with the group. Even when I wanted to be a part of said group. In school, this was considered weird, and for many years I was the outsider.
The goal of school was to be popular, and many people worked very hard at it. I did not. I believed the teachers when they said the point of school was to learn and get good grades. So I tried very hard to learn and didn't bother much with popularity, since it didn't seem to have any bearing on learning. Which it didn't. Learning and being popular are two entirely separate, though not necessarily exclusive, goals of the grade school child.
But which one you choose to focus on says a lot about who you are. The popular kids worked very hard on their image. They wore the right clothes, had the right accessories, all of them looked good. There were no ugly popular people. But they also tended to be outgoing. They were the showoffs, charismatic, always putting themselves out front where people could see them. What was important was not what they did, but who they were. Their goal was status.
At the bottom of the social heap were the geeks. These were the people who never even realized they were supposed to climb the social ladder (as opposed to those who were simply bad at it). They were the doers. They worked very hard at learning new things, building, trying new ideas. The geeks had their side projects and hobbies, but generally neglected to develop their social skills or fashion sense. What was important was what they did, and who they were was ignored. Their goal was accomplishment.
So you end up with two classes of people, those to whom it is important to belong, and those to whom it is important to do. The belongers are collectivists. They think it's important to belong to a group, which means going along with that the group does, regardless of what it means. The doers are individualists. They think it's important to make the right decisions, regardless of what the group thinks.
In looking at biblical principle, I realize that people are made to do both: belong and do. Humans are made to have relationships, to belong to a group or family. But we are also made to do, to create, to 'subdue the earth.' So both individualists and collectivists are following their human nature. The problems occur when you place all your focus and importance on one or the other.
It has been my experience that individualists have less trouble doing both than collectivists. Individualists still have relationships; we still have our groups to which we belong. It may be harder for us to form relationships, having neglected social skills in pursuit of some project, but few individualists are complete loners.
Collectivists, on the other hand, seem to have trouble accepting doing as important. They want to be popular or fashionable, and they aren't concerned with whether it makes any sense. As long as it's what the group wants, they'll do it. Here, the skilled are those who can recognize which trends will become fashionable so they can be the first ones on it. These are the leaders of the collectivists, the most popular.
But notice something. Collectivists fashion (at least in politics) is always described as doing something. Saving the environment, reducing poverty, educating the poor. It's all phrased as some kind of worthy goal. Who doesn't want to reduce poverty? But what is important to the collectivists isn't the goal, it is being part of the group working on the problem. It doesn't matter if they are actually accomplishing anything, or even if they are actually causing more problems, as long as everyone can see that they are part of the group that's 'solving' the problem.
This is one of the reasons for the political clashes in America. Individualists argue results and methods, saying that this program isn't helping or is causing the problem it purports to solve. Collectivists argue that certain people aren't in the Problem Solving Group and therefore don't care about the problem or want it to continue. So individualists say collectivists aren't achieving their stated goal and collectivists say that individualists aren't joining the group that's working on the problem. Both sides have valid arguments, but neither side is correct.
The problem is that collectivists believe that if everyone comes together in one big unified group, the problem would be solved. I have seen no evidence that this belief is true. The problem can, in fact, usually be solved, and it often takes a number of people working together to achieve it. But the act of unifying itself is not a solution. It is a means to an end. Collectivists treat it as an end.
At achieving this end, collectivists are quite successful. At least among fellow collectivists. Individualists of course don't believe in unifying for the sake of unifying. They want some purpose for the group to be working towards. Hence why collectivists' movements are defined in terms of accomplishing something. That gets individualists to join the movement, even though the real goal is really to show how fashionable you are. Interestingly, this would put the individualists at the bottom of the group's hierarchy, since they are actually trying to solve the problem, rather than working their way up the group.
So long as both sides pretend the goal is to solve the problem, then collectivists win over time. That is, their approach becomes the prevailing view. This is because individualists are still out accomplishing things (sometimes in the name of some collectivist group) while collectivists themselves sell everyone on the idea that coming together is what solved the problem. But eventually, we will reach a point where there are not enough doers out doing stuff, and too many people just being a part of the group.
When this happens, society will stagnate. You will have a great many people working very hard at... something. People won't be able to say what effect they are having, but they can definitely say they are working at it. Production, and thus wealth, will decline as more people concern themselves more with organization than with creating. But individualists will never go away. There will always be some people, however marginalized, that refuse to go along with the group and instead go off and accomplish something. Remember that doing is as much a part of human nature as belonging. When the individualists can no longer support the collectivists, the group will simply collapse, and all the vaunted unity will disappear, to be replaced by a bunch of individualists who will preserve what they may and start rebuilding.
The other week I was teaching a co-ed bible study. We were going over 1 Peter. We had read the whole thing through several times, and were then stepping through it verse by verse, chapter by chapter. But we ran into trouble when we started going though chapter 3.
3 Wives, in the same way be submissive to your husbands so that, if any of them do not believe the word, they may be won over without words by the behavior of their wives, 2when they see the purity and reverence of your lives. 3Your beauty should not come from outward adornment, such as braided hair and the wearing of gold jewelry and fine clothes. 4Instead, it should be that of your inner self, the unfading beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is of great worth in God's sight. 5For this is the way holy women of the past who put their hope in God used to make themselves beautiful. They were submissive to their own husbands, 6like Sarah, who obeyed Abraham and called him her master. You are her daughters if you do what is right and do not give way to fear.Some of the women in the room did not appreciate being told they had to submit to their husbands. Note that this is a singles bible study and no one in the room actually had a husband yet that they could submit to. But they did not even like the idea. The men's reaction to this passage was along the lines of 'yeah, that's right!' which of course just made the women more offended.
Everyone there was a Christian, so I find it curious that people would disagree with one of God's commands. Not surprising, in fact I rather expected the reaction, but curious nonetheless.
So what is it about submission that so gets women's hackles up?
The root of the problem lies in the difference between how God ordered society and how America has ordered society. Here in America, post the feminist movement, women are considered equals, and often times betters, to men. Women either want to be in charge, or do not want men to be in charge, but in either case, women do not want anyone telling them what to do. It is anathema to our society to place limits on our behaviors. This is as true of men as women, but women have an organized movement to make sure nobody thinks it's acceptable to limit women.
This is in direct contrast to God's plan, which states that the wife submits to the husband, and the husband submits to God. Here, the husband is in charge of the family, responsible for its instruction and behavior. The wife is to assist in this, but follows the husband's lead in how to go about it.
You can see the conflict between the two approaches to family. The two are not reconcilable. There is no middle ground and can be no compromise. There is no half submission and half in charge. You can try running your family like a committee, but ultimately, when a decision has to be made and the husband and wife have two different ideas about it, one prevails and one is discarded. Whoever has the final say is the one running the family. This is not to say that two people can't talk things through, but still, at the end, a decision is made by someone and the other goes along with it.
So there is the reason for our curious response. We have been taught the world is a particular way, or at least should be a particular way. But we find in the bible that God made the world a different way. So Christians who have spent more time learning the world's ways than God's ways become flustered when the two contradict.
Categories
Archives
Contributors
- RogueDash1
- RogueDash1 is a Christian of the Southern Baptist persuasion, and a software engineer writing for embedded devices.
Favorite Blogs
-
-
What is Responsive Web Design?4 years ago
-
-
-
America Vs Poland: Vulvo Edition7 years ago
-
Message heard.6 years ago
-
-
-
Good Girls Love Bad Boys3 weeks ago
-
-
-
20 Things Liberalism Is….3 years ago
-
-
-
Closing Time12 years ago
-
Hello world!9 years ago
-
-
女性高額バイトにて風俗エステで稼げる「曜日・時間帯」はいつ?3 years ago
-
Wednesday Action Log 11-18-2621 hours ago
-
Hiatus12 years ago
-
-
Whiskeys Place is Moving!14 years ago
